Release: 1.1.0b1 | Release Date: not released

SQLAlchemy 1.1 Documentation

Changes and Migration

Project Versions

What’s New in SQLAlchemy 1.1?

About this Document

This document describes changes between SQLAlchemy version 1.0, at the moment the current release series of SQLAlchemy, and SQLAlchemy version 1.1, which is the current development series of SQLAlchemy.

As the 1.1 series is under development, issues that are targeted at this series can be seen under the 1.1 milestone. Please note that the set of issues within the milestone is not fixed; some issues may be moved to later milestones in order to allow for a timely release.

Document last updated: March 23, 2016


This guide introduces what’s new in SQLAlchemy version 1.1, and also documents changes which affect users migrating their applications from the 1.0 series of SQLAlchemy to 1.1.

Please carefully review the sections on behavioral changes for potentially backwards-incompatible changes in behavior.

Platform / Installer Changes

Setuptools is now required for install

SQLAlchemy’s file has for many years supported operation both with Setuptools installed and without; supporting a “fallback” mode that uses straight Distutils. As a Setuptools-less Python environment is now unheard of, and in order to support the featureset of Setuptools more fully, in particular to support py.test’s integration with it as well as things like “extras”, now depends on Setuptools fully.

더 보기

Installation Guide


Enabling / Disabling C Extension builds is only via environment variable

The C Extensions build by default during install as long as it is possible. To disable C extension builds, the DISABLE_SQLALCHEMY_CEXT environment variable was made available as of SQLAlchemy 0.8.6 / 0.9.4. The previous approach of using the --without-cextensions argument has been removed, as it relies on deprecated features of setuptools.


New Features and Improvements - ORM

New Session lifecycle events

The Session has long supported events that allow some degree of tracking of state changes to objects, including SessionEvents.before_attach(), SessionEvents.after_attach(), and SessionEvents.before_flush(). The Session documentation also documents major object states at Quickie Intro to Object States. However, there has never been system of tracking objects specifically as they pass through these transitions. Additionally, the status of “deleted” objects has historically been murky as the objects act somewhere between the “persistent” and “detached” states.

To clean up this area and allow the realm of session state transition to be fully transparent, a new series of events have been added that are intended to cover every possible way that an object might transition between states, and additionally the “deleted” status has been given its own official state name within the realm of session object states.

New State Transition Events

Transitions between all states of an object such as persistent, pending and others can now be intercepted in terms of a session-level event intended to cover a specific transition. Transitions as objects move into a Session, move out of a Session, and even all the transitions which occur when the transaction is rolled back using Session.rollback() are explicitly present in the interface of SessionEvents.

In total, there are ten new events. A summary of these events is in a newly written documentation section Object Lifecycle Events.

New Object State “deleted” is added, deleted objects no longer “persistent”

The persistent state of an object in the Session has always been documented as an object that has a valid database identity; however in the case of objects that were deleted within a flush, they have always been in a grey area where they are not really “detached” from the Session yet, because they can still be restored within a rollback, but are not really “persistent” because their database identity has been deleted and they aren’t present in the identity map.

To resolve this grey area given the new events, a new object state deleted is introduced. This state exists between the “persistent” and “detached” states. An object that is marked for deletion via Session.delete() remains in the “persistent” state until a flush proceeds; at that point, it is removed from the identity map, moves to the “deleted” state, and the SessionEvents.persistent_to_deleted() hook is invoked. If the Session object’s transaction is rolled back, the object is restored as persistent; the SessionEvents.deleted_to_persistent() transition is called. Otherwise if the Session object’s transaction is committed, the SessionEvents.deleted_to_detached() transition is invoked.

Additionally, the InstanceState.persistent accessor no longer returns True for an object that is in the new “deleted” state; instead, the InstanceState.deleted accessor has been enhanced to reliably report on this new state. When the object is detached, the InstanceState.deleted returns False and the InstanceState.detached accessor is True instead. To determine if an object was deleted either in the current transaction or in a previous transaction, use the InstanceState.was_deleted accessor.

Strong Identity Map is Deprecated

One of the inspirations for the new series of transition events was to enable leak-proof tracking of objects as they move in and out of the identity map, so that a “strong reference” may be maintained mirroring the object moving in and out of this map. With this new capability, there is no longer any need for the Session.weak_identity_map parameter and the corresponding StrongIdentityMap object. This option has remained in SQLAlchemy for many years as the “strong-referencing” behavior used to be the only behavior available, and many applications were written to assume this behavior. It has long been recommended that strong-reference tracking of objects not be an intrinsic job of the Session and instead be an application-level construct built as needed by the application; the new event model allows even the exact behavior of the strong identity map to be replicated. See Session Referencing Behavior for a new recipe illustrating how to replace the strong identity map.


Changes regarding “unhashable” types

The Query object has a well-known behavior of “deduping” returned rows that contain at least one ORM-mapped entity (e.g., a full mapped object, as opposed to individual column values). The primary purpose of this is so that the handling of entities works smoothly in conjunction with the identity map, including to accommodate for the duplicate entities normally represented within joined eager loading, as well as when joins are used for the purposes of filtering on additional columns.

This deduplication relies upon the hashability of the elements within the row. With the introduction of Postgresql’s special types like postgresql.ARRAY, postgresql.HSTORE and postgresql.JSON, the experience of types within rows being unhashable and encountering problems here is more prevalent than it was previously.

In fact, SQLAlchemy has since version 0.8 included a flag on datatypes that are noted as “unhashable”, however this flag was not used consistently on built in types. As described in ARRAY and JSON types now correctly specify “unhashable”, this flag is now set consistently for all of Postgresql’s “structural” types.

The “unhashable” flag is also set on the NullType type, as NullType is used to refer to any expression of unknown type.

Additionally, the treatment of a so-called “unhashable” type is slightly different than its been in previous releases; internally we are using the id() function to get a “hash value” from these structures, just as we would any ordinary mapped object. This replaces the previous approach which applied a counter to the object.


Specific checks added for passing mapped classes, instances as SQL literals

The typing system now has specific checks for passing of SQLAlchemy “inspectable” objects in contexts where they would otherwise be handled as literal values. Any SQLAlchemy built-in object that is legal to pass as a SQL value includes a method __clause_element__() which provides a valid SQL expression for that object. For SQLAlchemy objects that don’t provide this, such as mapped classes, mappers, and mapped instances, a more informative error message is emitted rather than allowing the DBAPI to receive the object and fail later. An example is illustrated below, where a string-based attribute is compared to a full instance of User(), rather than against a string value:

>>> some_user = User()
>>> q = s.query(User).filter( == some_user)
sqlalchemy.exc.ArgumentError: Object <__main__.User object at 0x103167e90> is not legal as a SQL literal value

The exception is now immediate when the comparison is made between == some_user. Previously, a comparison like the above would produce a SQL expression that would only fail once resolved into a DBAPI execution call; the mapped User object would ultimately become a bound parameter that would be rejected by the DBAPI.

Note that in the above example, the expression fails because is a string-based (e.g. column oriented) attribute. The change does not impact the usual case of comparing a many-to-one relationship attribute to an object, which is handled distinctly:

>>> # Address.user refers to the User mapper, so
>>> # this is of course still OK!
>>> q = s.query(Address).filter(Address.user == some_user)


New options allowing explicit persistence of NULL over a default

Related to the new JSON-NULL support added to Postgresql as part of JSON “null” is inserted as expected with ORM operations, regardless of column default present, the base TypeEngine class now supports a method TypeEngine.evaluates_none() which allows a positive set of the None value on an attribute to be persisted as NULL, rather than omitting the column from the INSERT statement, which has the effect of using the column-level default. This allows a mapper-level configuration of the existing object-level technique of assigning sql.null() to the attribute.


Further Fixes to single-table inheritance querying

Continuing from 1.0’s Change to single-table-inheritance criteria when using from_self(), count(), the Query should no longer inappropriately add the “single inheritance” criteria when the query is against a subquery expression such as an exists:

class Widget(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'widget'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    type = Column(String)
    data = Column(String)
    __mapper_args__ = {'polymorphic_on': type}

class FooWidget(Widget):
    __mapper_args__ = {'polymorphic_identity': 'foo'}

q = session.query(FooWidget).filter( == 'bar').exists()



FROM widget
WHERE = :data_1 AND widget.type IN (:type_1)) AS anon_1

The IN clause on the inside is appropriate, in order to limit to FooWidget objects, however previously the IN clause would also be generated a second time on the outside of the subquery.


Improved Session state when a SAVEPOINT is cancelled by the database

A common case with MySQL is that a SAVEPOINT is cancelled when a deadlock occurs within the transaction. The Session has been modfied to deal with this failure mode slightly more gracefully, such that the outer, non-savepoint transaction still remains usable:

s = Session()


    # assume the flush fails, flush goes to rollback to the
    # savepoint and that also fails
except Exception as err:
    print("Something broke, and our SAVEPOINT vanished too")

# this is the SAVEPOINT transaction, marked as
# DEACTIVE so the rollback() call succeeds

# this is the outermost transaction, remains ACTIVE
# so rollback() or commit() can succeed

This issue is a continuation of #2696 where we emit a warning so that the original error can be seen when running on Python 2, even though the SAVEPOINT exception takes precedence. On Python 3, exceptions are chained so both failures are reported individually.


Erroneous “new instance X conflicts with persistent instance Y” flush errors fixed

The Session.rollback() method is responsible for removing objects that were INSERTed into the database, e.g. moved from pending to persistent, within that now rolled-back transaction. Objects that make this state change are tracked in a weak-referencing collection, and if an object is garbage collected from that collection, the Session no longer worries about it (it would otherwise not scale for operations that insert many new objects within a transaction). However, an issue arises if the application re-loads that same garbage-collected row within the transaction, before the rollback occurs; if a strong reference to this object remains into the next transaction, the fact that this object was not inserted and should be removed would be lost, and the flush would incorrectly raise an error:

from sqlalchemy import Column, create_engine
from sqlalchemy.orm import Session
from sqlalchemy.ext.declarative import declarative_base

Base = declarative_base()

class A(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'a'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)

e = create_engine("sqlite://", echo=True)

s = Session(e)

# persist an object

# rollback buffer loses reference to A

# load it again, rollback buffer knows nothing
# about it
a1 = s.query(A).first()

# roll back the transaction; all state is expired but the
# "a1" reference remains

# previous "a1" conflicts with the new one because we aren't
# checking that it never got committed

The above program would raise:

FlushError: New instance <User at 0x7f0287eca4d0> with identity key
(<class 'test.orm.test_transaction.User'>, ('u1',)) conflicts
with persistent instance <User at 0x7f02889c70d0>

The bug is that when the above exception is raised, the unit of work is operating upon the original object assuming it’s a live row, when in fact the object is expired and upon testing reveals that it’s gone. The fix tests this condition now, so in the SQL log we see:

BEGIN (implicit)


(1, 0)


BEGIN (implicit)




Above, the unit of work now does a SELECT for the row we’re about to report as a conflict for, sees that it doesn’t exist, and proceeds normally. The expense of this SELECT is only incurred in the case when we would have erroneously raised an exception in any case.


passive_deletes feature for joined-inheritance mappings

A joined-table inheritance mapping may now allow a DELETE to proceed as a result of Session.delete(), which only emits DELETE for the base table, and not the subclass table, allowing configured ON DELETE CASCADE to take place for the configured foreign keys. This is configured using the orm.mapper.passive_deletes option:

from sqlalchemy import Column, Integer, String, ForeignKey, create_engine
from sqlalchemy.orm import Session
from sqlalchemy.ext.declarative import declarative_base

Base = declarative_base()

class A(Base):
    __tablename__ = "a"
    id = Column('id', Integer, primary_key=True)
    type = Column(String)

    __mapper_args__ = {
        'polymorphic_on': type,
        'polymorphic_identity': 'a',
        'passive_deletes': True

class B(A):
    __tablename__ = 'b'
    b_table_id = Column('b_table_id', Integer, primary_key=True)
    bid = Column('bid', Integer, ForeignKey('', ondelete="CASCADE"))
    data = Column('data', String)

    __mapper_args__ = {
        'polymorphic_identity': 'b'

With the above mapping, the orm.mapper.passive_deletes option is configured on the base mapper; it takes effect for all non-base mappers that are descendants of the mapper with the option set. A DELETE for an object of type B no longer needs to retrieve the primary key value of b_table_id if unloaded, nor does it need to emit a DELETE statement for the table itself:


Will emit SQL as:

{'id': 1}

As always, the target database must have foreign key support with ON DELETE CASCADE enabled.


Same-named backrefs will not raise an error when applied to concrete inheritance subclasses

The following mapping has always been possible without issue:

class A(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'a'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    b = relationship("B", foreign_keys="B.a_id", backref="a")

class A1(A):
    __tablename__ = 'a1'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    b = relationship("B", foreign_keys="B.a1_id", backref="a1")
    __mapper_args__ = {'concrete': True}

class B(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'b'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)

    a_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))
    a1_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))

Above, even though class A and class A1 have a relationship named b, no conflict warning or error occurs because class A1 is marked as “concrete”.

However, if the relationships were configured the other way, an error would occur:

class A(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'a'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)

class A1(A):
    __tablename__ = 'a1'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    __mapper_args__ = {'concrete': True}

class B(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'b'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)

    a_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))
    a1_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))

    a = relationship("A", backref="b")
    a1 = relationship("A1", backref="b")

The fix enhances the backref feature so that an error is not emitted, as well as an additional check within the mapper logic to bypass warning for an attribute being replaced.


Session.merge resolves pending conflicts the same as persistent

The Session.merge() method will now track the identities of objects given within a graph to maintain primary key uniqueness before emitting an INSERT. When duplicate objects of the same identity are encountered, non-primary-key attributes are overwritten as the objects are encountered, which is essentially non-deterministic. This behavior matches that of how persistent objects, that is objects that are already located in the database via primary key, are already treated, so this behavior is more internally consistent.


u1 = User(id=7, name='x')
u1.orders = [
    Order(description='o1', address=Address(id=1, email_address='a')),
    Order(description='o2', address=Address(id=1, email_address='b')),
    Order(description='o3', address=Address(id=1, email_address='c'))

sess = Session()

Above, we merge a User object with three new Order objects, each referring to a distinct Address object, however each is given the same primary key. The current behavior of Session.merge() is to look in the identity map for this Address object, and use that as the target. If the object is present, meaning that the database already has a row for Address with primary key “1”, we can see that the email_address field of the Address will be overwritten three times, in this case with the values a, b and finally c.

However, if the Address row for primary key “1” were not present, Session.merge() would instead create three separate Address instances, and we’d then get a primary key conflict upon INSERT. The new behavior is that the proposed primary key for these Address objects are tracked in a separate dictionary so that we merge the state of the three proposed Address objects onto one Address object to be inserted.

It may have been preferable if the original case emitted some kind of warning that conflicting data were present in a single merge-tree, however the non-deterministic merging of values has been the behavior for many years for the persistent case; it now matches for the pending case. A feature that warns for conflicting values could still be feasible for both cases but would add considerable performance overhead as each column value would have to be compared during the merge.


Improvements to the Query.correlate method with polymoprhic entities

In recent SQLAlchemy versions, the SQL generated by many forms of “polymorphic” queries has a more “flat” form than it used to, where a JOIN of several tables is no longer bundled into a subquery unconditionally. To accommodate this, the Query.correlate() method now extracts the individual tables from such a polymorphic selectable and ensures that all are part of the “correlate” for the subquery. Assuming the Person/Manager/Engineer->Company setup from the mapping documentation, using with_polymorphic:

                filter(Company.company_id == Person.company_id).
                correlate(Person).as_scalar() == "Elbonia, Inc.")

The above query now produces:

SELECT AS people_name
FROM people
LEFT OUTER JOIN engineers ON people.person_id = engineers.person_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN managers ON people.person_id = managers.person_id
FROM companies
WHERE companies.company_id = people.company_id) = ?

Before the fix, the call to correlate(Person) would inadvertently attempt to correlate to the join of Person, Engineer and Manager as a single unit, so Person wouldn’t be correlated:

-- old, incorrect query
SELECT AS people_name
FROM people
LEFT OUTER JOIN engineers ON people.person_id = engineers.person_id
LEFT OUTER JOIN managers ON people.person_id = managers.person_id
FROM companies, people
WHERE companies.company_id = people.company_id) = ?

Using correlated subqueries against polymorphic mappings still has some unpolished edges. If for example Person is polymorphically linked to a so-called “concrete polymorphic union” query, the above subquery may not correctly refer to this subquery. In all cases, a way to refer to the “polyorphic” entity fully is to create an aliased() object from it first:

# works with all SQLAlchemy versions and all types of polymorphic
# aliasing.

paliased = aliased(Person)
                filter(Company.company_id == paliased.company_id).
                correlate(paliased).as_scalar() == "Elbonia, Inc.")

The aliased() construct guarantees that the “polymorphic selectable” is wrapped in a subquery. By referring to it explicitly in the correlated subquery, the polymorphic form is correctly used.


Stringify of Query will consult the Session for the correct dialect

Calling str() on a Query object will consult the Session for the correct “bind” to use, in order to render the SQL that would be passed to the database. In particular this allows a Query that refers to dialect-specific SQL constructs to be renderable, assuming the Query is associated with an appropriate Session. Previously, this behavior would only take effect if the MetaData to which the mappings were associated were itself bound to the target Engine.

If neither the underlying MetaData nor the Session are associated with any bound Engine, then the fallback to the “default” dialect is used to generate the SQL string.


Joined eager loading where the same entity is present multiple times in one row

A fix has been made to the case has been made whereby an attribute will be loaded via joined eager loading, even if the entity was already loaded from the row on a different “path” that doesn’t include the attribute. This is a deep use case that’s hard to reproduce, but the general idea is as follows:

class A(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'a'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    b_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))
    c_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))

    b = relationship("B")
    c = relationship("C")

class B(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'b'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    c_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))

    c = relationship("C")

class C(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'c'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    d_id = Column(ForeignKey(''))
    d = relationship("D")

class D(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'd'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)

c_alias_1 = aliased(C)
c_alias_2 = aliased(C)

q = s.query(A)
q = q.join(A.b).join(c_alias_1, B.c).join(c_alias_1.d)
q = q.options(contains_eager(A.b).contains_eager(B.c, alias=c_alias_1).contains_eager(C.d))
q = q.join(c_alias_2, A.c)
q = q.options(contains_eager(A.c, alias=c_alias_2))

The above query emits SQL like this:

SELECT AS d_id, AS c_1_id, c_1.d_id AS c_1_d_id, AS b_id, b.c_id AS b_c_id, AS c_2_id, c_2.d_id AS c_2_d_id, AS a_id, a.b_id AS a_b_id, a.c_id AS a_c_id
    JOIN b ON = a.b_id
    JOIN c AS c_1 ON = b.c_id
    JOIN d ON = c_1.d_id
    JOIN c AS c_2 ON = a.c_id

We can see that the c table is selected from twice; once in the context of A.b.c -> c_alias_1 and another in the context of A.c -> c_alias_2. Also, we can see that it is quite possible that the C identity for a single row is the same for both c_alias_1 and c_alias_2, meaning two sets of columns in one row result in only one new object being added to the identity map.

The query options above only call for the attribute C.d to be loaded in the context of c_alias_1, and not c_alias_2. So whether or not the final C object we get in the identity map has the C.d attribute loaded depends on how the mappings are traversed, which while not completely random, is essentially non-deterministic. The fix is that even if the loader for c_alias_1 is processed after that of c_alias_2 for a single row where they both refer to the same identity, the C.d element will still be loaded. Previously, the loader did not seek to modify the load of an entity that was already loaded via a different path. The loader that reaches the entity first has always been non-deterministic, so this fix may be detectable as a behavioral change in some situations and not others.

The fix includes tests for two variants of the “multiple paths to one entity” case, and the fix should hopefully cover all other scenarios of this nature.


Columns no longer added redundantly with DISTINCT + ORDER BY

A query such as the following will now augment only those columns that are missing from the SELECT list, without duplicates:

q = session.query(,'name')).\
    order_by(,, User.fullname)


 user.fullname AS a_fullname
FROM a ORDER BY,, user.fullname

Previously, it would produce:

SELECT DISTINCT AS a_id, AS name, AS a_name,
  user.fullname AS a_fullname
FROM a ORDER BY,, user.fullname

Where above, the column is added unnecessarily. The results would not be affected, as the additional columns are not included in the result in any case, but the columns are unnecessary.

Additionally, when the Postgresql DISTINCT ON format is used by passing expressions to Query.distinct(), the above “column adding” logic is disabled entirely.

When the query is being bundled into a subquery for the purposes of joined eager loading, the “augment column list” rules are are necessarily more aggressive so that the ORDER BY can still be satisifed, so this case remains unchanged.


New MutableList and MutableSet helpers added to the mutation tracking extension

New helper classes MutableList and MutableSet have been added to the Mutation Tracking extension, to complement the existing MutableDict helper.


New Features and Improvements - Core


One of the most widely requested features is support for common table expressions (CTE) that work with INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE, and is now implemented. An INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE can both draw from a WITH clause that’s stated at the top of the SQL, as well as can be used as a CTE itself in the context of a larger statement.

As part of this change, an INSERT from SELECT that includes a CTE will now render the CTE at the top of the entire statement, rather than nested in the SELECT statement as was the case in 1.0.

Below is an example that renders UPDATE, INSERT and SELECT all in one statement:

>>> from sqlalchemy import table, column, select, literal, exists
>>> orders = table(
...     'orders',
...     column('region'),
...     column('amount'),
...     column('product'),
...     column('quantity')
... )
>>> upsert = (
...     orders.update()
...     .where(orders.c.region == 'Region1')
...     .values(amount=1.0, product='Product1', quantity=1)
...     .returning(*(orders.c._all_columns)).cte('upsert'))
>>> insert = orders.insert().from_select(
...     orders.c.keys(),
...     select([
...         literal('Region1'), literal(1.0),
...         literal('Product1'), literal(1)
...     ]).where(~exists(
... )
>>> print(insert)  # note formatting added for clarity
WITH upsert AS
(UPDATE orders SET amount=:amount, product=:product, quantity=:quantity
 WHERE orders.region = :region_1
 RETURNING orders.region, orders.amount, orders.product, orders.quantity
INSERT INTO orders (region, amount, product, quantity)
    :param_1 AS anon_1, :param_2 AS anon_2,
    :param_3 AS anon_3, :param_4 AS anon_4
    EXISTS (
        SELECT upsert.region, upsert.amount,
               upsert.product, upsert.quantity
        FROM upsert))


Support for the SQL LATERAL keyword

The LATERAL keyword is currently known to only be supported by Postgresql 9.3 and greater, however as it is part of the SQL standard support for this keyword is added to Core. The implementation of Select.lateral() employs special logic beyond just rendering the LATERAL keyword to allow for correlation of tables that are derived from the same FROM clause as the selectable, e.g. lateral correlation:

>>> from sqlalchemy import table, column, select, true
>>> people = table('people', column('people_id'), column('age'), column('name'))
>>> books = table('books', column('book_id'), column('owner_id'))
>>> subq = select([books.c.book_id]).\
...      where(books.c.owner_id == people.c.people_id).lateral("book_subq")
>>> print (select([people]).select_from(people.join(subq, true())))
SELECT people.people_id, people.age,
FROM people JOIN LATERAL (SELECT books.book_id AS book_id
FROM books WHERE books.owner_id = people.people_id)
AS book_subq ON true


The .autoincrement directive is no longer implicitly enabled for a composite primary key column

SQLAlchemy has always had the convenience feature of enabling the backend database’s “autoincrement” feature for a single-column integer primary key; by “autoincrement” we mean that the database column will include whatever DDL directives the database provides in order to indicate an auto-incrementing integer identifier, such as the SERIAL keyword on Postgresql or AUTO_INCREMENT on MySQL, and additionally that the dialect will recieve these generated values from the execution of a Table.insert() construct using techniques appropriate to that backend.

What’s changed is that this feature no longer turns on automatically for a composite primary key; previously, a table definition such as:

    'some_table', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True)

Would have “autoincrement” semantics applied to the 'x' column, only because it’s first in the list of primary key columns. In order to disable this, one would have to turn off autoincrement on all columns:

# old way
    'some_table', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True, autoincrement=False),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True, autoincrement=False)

With the new behavior, the composite primary key will not have autoincrement semantics unless a column is marked explcitly with autoincrement=True:

# column 'y' will be SERIAL/AUTO_INCREMENT/ auto-generating
    'some_table', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True, autoincrement=True)

In order to anticipate some potential backwards-incompatible scenarios, the Table.insert() construct will perform more thorough checks for missing primary key values on composite primary key columns that don’t have autoincrement set up; given a table such as:

    'b', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True)

An INSERT emitted with no values for this table will produce the exception:

CompileError: Column 'b.x' is marked as a member of the primary
key for table 'b', but has no Python-side or server-side default
generator indicated, nor does it indicate 'autoincrement=True',
and no explicit value is passed.  Primary key columns may not
store NULL. Note that as of SQLAlchemy 1.1, 'autoincrement=True'
must be indicated explicitly for composite (e.g. multicolumn)
primary keys if AUTO_INCREMENT/SERIAL/IDENTITY behavior is
expected for one of the columns in the primary key. CREATE TABLE
statements are impacted by this change as well on most backends.

For a column that is receiving primary key values from a server-side default or something less common such as a trigger, the presence of a value generator can be indicated using FetchedValue:

    'b', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True, server_default=FetchedValue()),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True, server_default=FetchedValue())

For the very unlikely case where a composite primary key is actually intended to store NULL in one or more of its columns (only supported on SQLite and MySQL), specify the column with nullable=True:

    'b', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True, nullable=True)

In a related change, the autoincrement flag may be set to True on a column that has a client-side or server-side default. This typically will not have much impact on the behavior of the column during an INSERT.


Core and ORM support for FULL OUTER JOIN

The new flag FromClause.outerjoin.full, available at the Core and ORM level, instructs the compiler to render FULL OUTER JOIN where it would normally render LEFT OUTER JOIN:

stmt = select([t1]).select_from(t1.outerjoin(t2, full=True))

The flag also works at the ORM level:

q = session.query(MyClass).outerjoin(MyOtherClass, full=True)


ResultSet column matching enhancements; positional column setup for textual SQL

A series of improvements were made to the ResultProxy system in the 1.0 series as part of #918, which reorganizes the internals to match cursor-bound result columns with table/ORM metadata positionally, rather than by matching names, for compiled SQL constructs that contain full information about the result rows to be returned. This allows a dramatic savings on Python overhead as well as much greater accuracy in linking ORM and Core SQL expressions to result rows. In 1.1, this reorganization has been taken further internally, and also has been made available to pure-text SQL constructs via the use of the recently added TextClause.columns() method.

TextAsFrom.columns() now works positionally

The TextClause.columns() method, added in 0.9, accepts column-based arguments positionally; in 1.1, when all columns are passed positionally, the correlation of these columns to the ultimate result set is also performed positionally. The key advantage here is that textual SQL can now be linked to an ORM- level result set without the need to deal with ambiguous or duplicate column names, or with having to match labeling schemes to ORM-level labeling schemes. All that’s needed now is the same ordering of columns within the textual SQL and the column arguments passed to TextClause.columns():

from sqlalchemy import text
stmt = text("SELECT,,, "
     ", addresses.email_address AS email "
     "FROM users JOIN addresses ON "
     "WHERE = 1").columns(,,

query = session.query(User).from_statement(text).\
result = query.all()

Above, the textual SQL contains the column “id” three times, which would normally be ambiguous. Using the new feature, we can apply the mapped columns from the User and Address class directly, even linking the Address.user_id column to the column in textual SQL for fun, and the Query object will receive rows that are correctly targetable as needed, including for an eager load.

This change is backwards incompatible with code that passes the columns to the method with a different ordering than is present in the textual statement. It is hoped that this impact will be low due to the fact that this method has always been documented illustrating the columns being passed in the same order as that of the textual SQL statement, as would seem intuitive, even though the internals weren’t checking for this. The method itself was only added as of 0.9 in any case and may not yet have widespread use. Notes on exactly how to handle this behavioral change for applications using it are at TextClause.columns() will match columns positionally, not by name, when passed positionally.

Positional matching is trusted over name-based matching for Core/ORM SQL constructs

Another aspect of this change is that the rules for matching columns have also been modified to rely upon “positional” matching more fully for compiled SQL constructs as well. Given a statement like the following:

ua = users.alias('ua')
stmt = select([users.c.user_id, ua.c.user_id])

The above statement will compile to:

SELECT users.user_id, ua.user_id FROM users, users AS ua

In 1.0, the above statement when executed would be matched to its original compiled construct using positional matching, however because the statement contains the 'user_id' label duplicated, the “ambiguous column” rule would still get involved and prevent the columns from being fetched from a row. As of 1.1, the “ambiguous column” rule does not affect an exact match from a column construct to the SQL column, which is what the ORM uses to fetch columns:

result = conn.execute(stmt)
row = result.first()

# these both match positionally, so no error
user_id = row[users.c.user_id]
ua_id = row[ua.c.user_id]

# this still raises, however
user_id = row['user_id']

Much less likely to get an “ambiguous column” error message

As part of this change, the wording of the error message Ambiguous column name '<name>' in result set! try 'use_labels' option on select statement. has been dialed back; as this message should now be extremely rare when using the ORM or Core compiled SQL constructs, it merely states Ambiguous column name '<name>' in result set column descriptions, and only when a result column is retrieved using the string name that is actually ambiguous, e.g. row['user_id'] in the above example. It also now refers to the actual ambiguous name from the rendered SQL statement itself, rather than indicating the key or name that was local to the construct being used for the fetch.


Support for Python’s native enum type and compatible forms

The Enum type can now be constructed using any PEP-435 compliant enumerated type. When using this mode, input values and return values are the actual enumerated objects, not the string values:

import enum
from sqlalchemy import Table, MetaData, Column, Enum, create_engine

class MyEnum(enum.Enum):
    one = "one"
    two = "two"
    three = "three"

t = Table(
    'data', MetaData(),
    Column('value', Enum(MyEnum))

e = create_engine("sqlite://")

e.execute(t.insert(), {"value": MyEnum.two})
assert e.scalar( is MyEnum.two


Negative integer indexes accommodated by Core result rows

The RowProxy object now accomodates single negative integer indexes like a regular Python sequence, both in the pure Python and C-extension version. Previously, negative values would only work in slices:

>>> from sqlalchemy import create_engine
>>> e = create_engine("sqlite://")
>>> row = e.execute("select 1, 2, 3").first()
>>> row[-1], row[-2], row[1], row[-2:2]
3 2 2 (2,)

The Enum type now does in-Python validation of values

To accomodate for Python native enumerated objects, as well as for edge cases such as that of where a non-native ENUM type is used within an ARRAY and a CHECK contraint is infeasible, the Enum datatype now adds in-Python validation of input values:

>>> from sqlalchemy import Table, MetaData, Column, Enum, create_engine
>>> t = Table(
...     'data', MetaData(),
...     Column('value', Enum("one", "two", "three"))
... )
>>> e = create_engine("sqlite://")
>>> t.create(e)
>>> e.execute(t.insert(), {"value": "four"})
Traceback (most recent call last):
sqlalchemy.exc.StatementError: (exceptions.LookupError)
"four" is not among the defined enum values
[SQL: u'INSERT INTO data (value) VALUES (?)']
[parameters: [{'value': 'four'}]]

For simplicity and consistency, this validation is now turned on in all cases, whether or not the enumerated type uses a database-native form, whether or not the CHECK constraint is in use, as well as whether or not a PEP-435 enumerated type or plain list of string values is used. The check also occurs on the result-handling side as well, when values coming from the database are returned.

This validation is in addition to the existing behavior of creating a CHECK constraint when a non-native enumerated type is used. The creation of this CHECK constraint can now be disabled using the new Enum.create_constraint flag.


Large parameter and row values are now truncated in logging and exception displays

A large value present as a bound parameter for a SQL statement, as well as a large value present in a result row, will now be truncated during display within logging, exception reporting, as well as repr() of the row itself:

>>> from sqlalchemy import create_engine
>>> import random
>>> e = create_engine("sqlite://", echo='debug')
>>> some_value = ''.join(chr(random.randint(52, 85)) for i in range(5000))
>>> row = e.execute("select ?", [some_value]).first()
... (lines are wrapped for clarity) ...
2016-02-17 13:23:03,027 INFO sqlalchemy.engine.base.Engine select ?
2016-02-17 13:23:03,027 INFO sqlalchemy.engine.base.Engine
GJ7HQ6 ... (4702 characters truncated) ... J6IK546AJMB4N6S9L;;9AKI;=RJP
2016-02-17 13:23:03,027 DEBUG sqlalchemy.engine.base.Engine Col ('?',)
2016-02-17 13:23:03,027 DEBUG sqlalchemy.engine.base.Engine
Row (u'E6@?>9HPOJB<<BHR:@=TS:5ILU=;JLM<4?B9<S48PTNG9>:=TSTLA;9K;9FPM4M8M@;
>4=4:PGJ7HQ ... (4703 characters truncated) ... J6IK546AJMB4N6S9L;;9AKI;=
>>> print row
=4:PGJ7HQ ... (4703 characters truncated) ... J6IK546AJMB4N6S9L;;9AKI;


A UNION or similar of SELECTs with LIMIT/OFFSET/ORDER BY now parenthesizes the embedded selects

An issue that, like others, was long driven by SQLite’s lack of capabilities has now been enhanced to work on all supporting backends. We refer to a query that is a UNION of SELECT statements that themselves contain row-limiting or ordering features which include LIMIT, OFFSET, and/or ORDER BY:


The above query requires parenthesis within each sub-select in order to group the sub-results correctly. Production of the above statement in SQLAlchemy Core looks like:

stmt1 = select([table1.c.x]).order_by(table1.c.y).limit(1)
stmt2 = select([table1.c.x]).order_by(table2.c.y).limit(2)

stmt = union(stmt1, stmt2)

Previously, the above construct would not produce parenthesization for the inner SELECT statements, producing a query that fails on all backends.

The above formats will continue to fail on SQLite; additionally, the format that includes ORDER BY but no LIMIT/SELECT will continue to fail on Oracle. This is not a backwards-incompatible change, because the queries fail without the parentheses as well; with the fix, the queries at least work on all other databases.

In all cases, in order to produce a UNION of limited SELECT statements that also works on SQLite and in all cases on Oracle, the subqueries must be a SELECT of an ALIAS:

stmt1 = select([table1.c.x]).order_by(table1.c.y).limit(1).alias().select()
stmt2 = select([table2.c.x]).order_by(table2.c.y).limit(2).alias().select()

stmt = union(stmt1, stmt2)

This workaround works on all SQLAlchemy versions. In the ORM, it looks like:

stmt1 = session.query(Model1).order_by(Model1.y).limit(1).subquery().select()
stmt2 = session.query(Model2).order_by(Model2.y).limit(1).subquery().select()

stmt = session.query(Model1).from_statement(stmt1.union(stmt2))

The behavior here has many parallels to the “join rewriting” behavior introduced in SQLAlchemy 0.9 in Many JOIN and LEFT OUTER JOIN expressions will no longer be wrapped in (SELECT * FROM ..) AS ANON_1; however in this case we have opted not to add new rewriting behavior to accommodate this case for SQLite. The existing rewriting behavior is very complicated already, and the case of UNIONs with parenthesized SELECT statements is much less common than the “right-nested-join” use case of that feature.


JSON support added to Core

As MySQL now has a JSON datatype in addition to the Postgresql JSON datatype, the core now gains a sqlalchemy.types.JSON datatype that is the basis for both of these. Using this type allows access to the “getitem” operator as well as the “getpath” operator in a way that is agnostic across Postgresql and MySQL.

The new datatype also has a series of improvements to the handling of NULL values as well as expression handling.


JSON “null” is inserted as expected with ORM operations, regardless of column default present

The types.JSON type and its descendant types postgresql.JSON and mysql.JSON have a flag types.JSON.none_as_null which when set to True indicates that the Python value None should translate into a SQL NULL rather than a JSON NULL value. This flag defaults to False, which means that the column should never insert SQL NULL or fall back to a default unless the null() constant were used. However, this would fail in the ORM under two circumstances; one is when the column also contained a default or server_default value, a positive value of None on the mapped attribute would still result in the column-level default being triggered, replacing the None value:

obj = MyObject(json_value=None)
session.commit()   # would fire off default / server_default, not encode "'none'"

The other is when the Session.bulk_insert_mappings() method were used, None would be ignored in all cases:

    [{"json_value": None}])  # would insert SQL NULL and/or trigger defaults

The types.JSON type now implements the TypeEngine.should_evaluate_none flag, indicating that None should not be ignored here; it is configured automatically based on the value of types.JSON.none_as_null. Thanks to #3061, we can differentiate when the value None is actively set by the user versus when it was never set at all.

If the attribute is not set at all, then column level defaults will fire off and/or SQL NULL will be inserted as expected, as was the behavior previously. Below, the two variants are illustrated:

obj = MyObject(json_value=None)
session.commit()   # *will not* fire off column defaults, will insert JSON 'null'

obj = MyObject()
session.commit()   # *will* fire off column defaults, and/or insert SQL NULL

The feature applies as well to the new base types.JSON type and its descendant types.


New JSON.NULL Constant Added

To ensure that an application can always have full control at the value level of whether a types.JSON, postgresql.JSON, mysql.JSON, or postgresql.JSONB column should receive a SQL NULL or JSON "null" value, the constant types.JSON.NULL has been added, which in conjunction with null() can be used to determine fully between SQL NULL and JSON "null", regardless of what types.JSON.none_as_null is set to:

from sqlalchemy import null
from sqlalchemy.dialects.postgresql import JSON

obj1 = MyObject(json_value=null())  # will *always* insert SQL NULL
obj2 = MyObject(json_value=JSON.NULL)  # will *always* insert JSON string "null"

session.add_all([obj1, obj2])

The feature applies as well to the new base types.JSON type and its descendant types.


Array support added to Core; new ANY and ALL operators

Along with the enhancements made to the Postgresql postgresql.ARRAY type described in Correct SQL Types are Established from Indexed Access of ARRAY, JSON, HSTORE, the base class of postgresql.ARRAY itself has been moved to Core in a new class types.ARRAY.

Arrays are part of the SQL standard, as are several array-oriented functions such as array_agg() and unnest(). In support of these constructs for not just PostgreSQL but also potentially for other array-capable backends in the future such as DB2, the majority of array logic for SQL expressions is now in Core. The types.ARRAY type still only works on Postgresql, however it can be used directly, supporting special array use cases such as indexed access, as well as support for the ANY and ALL:

mytable = Table("mytable", metadata,
        Column("data", ARRAY(Integer, dimensions=2))

expr =[5][6]

expr =[5].any(12)

In support of ANY and ALL, the types.ARRAY type retains the same types.ARRAY.Comparator.any() and types.ARRAY.Comparator.all() methods from the PostgreSQL type, but also exports these operations to new standalone operator functions sql.expression.any_() and sql.expression.all_(). These two functions work in more of the traditional SQL way, allowing a right-side expression form such as:

from sqlalchemy import any_, all_

select([mytable]).where(12 == any_([5]))

For the PostgreSQL-specific operators “contains”, “contained_by”, and “overlaps”, one should continue to use the postgresql.ARRAY type directly, which provides all functionality of the types.ARRAY type as well.

The sql.expression.any_() and sql.expression.all_() operators are open-ended at the Core level, however their interpretation by backend databases is limited. On the Postgresql backend, the two operators only accept array values. Whereas on the MySQL backend, they only accept subquery values. On MySQL, one can use an expression such as:

from sqlalchemy import any_, all_

subq = select([mytable.c.value])
select([mytable]).where(12 > any_(subq))


New Function features, “WITHIN GROUP”, array_agg and set aggregate functions

With the new types.ARRAY type we can also implement a pre-typed function for the array_agg() SQL function that returns an array, which is now available using array_agg:

from sqlalchemy import func
stmt = select([func.array_agg(table.c.value)])

A Postgresql element for an aggregate ORDER BY is also added via postgresql.aggregate_order_by:

from sqlalchemy.dialects.postgresql import aggregate_order_by
expr = func.array_agg(aggregate_order_by(table.c.a, table.c.b.desc()))
stmt = select([expr])


SELECT array_agg(table1.a ORDER BY table1.b DESC) AS array_agg_1 FROM table1

The PG dialect itself also provides an postgresql.array_agg() wrapper to ensure the postgresql.ARRAY type:

from sqlalchemy.dialects.postgresql import array_agg
stmt = select([array_agg(table.c.value).contains('foo')])

Additionally, functions like percentile_cont(), percentile_disc(), rank(), dense_rank() and others that require an ordering via WITHIN GROUP (ORDER BY <expr>) are now available via the FunctionElement.within_group() modifier:

from sqlalchemy import func
stmt = select([,

The above statement would produce SQL similar to:

SELECT, percentile_cont(0.5)
WITHIN GROUP (ORDER BY department.salary DESC)

Placeholders with correct return types are now provided for these functions, and include percentile_cont, percentile_disc, rank, dense_rank, mode, percent_rank, and cume_dist.

#3132 #1370

TypeDecorator now works with Enum, Boolean, “schema” types automatically

The SchemaType types include types such as Enum and Boolean which, in addition to corresponding to a database type, also generate either a CHECK constraint or in the case of Postgresql ENUM a new CREATE TYPE statement, will now work automatically with TypeDecorator recipes. Previously, a TypeDecorator for an postgresql.ENUM had to look like this:

# old way
class MyEnum(TypeDecorator, SchemaType):
    impl = postgresql.ENUM('one', 'two', 'three', name='myenum')

    def _set_table(self, table):

The TypeDecorator now propagates those additional events so it can be done like any other type:

# new way
class MyEnum(TypeDecorator):
    impl = postgresql.ENUM('one', 'two', 'three', name='myenum')


Multi-Tenancy Schema Translation for Table objects

To support the use case of an application that uses the same set of Table objects in many schemas, such as schema-per-user, a new execution option Connection.execution_options.schema_translate_map is added. Using this mapping, a set of Table objects can be made on a per-connection basis to refer to any set of schemas instead of the Table.schema to which they were assigned. The translation works for DDL and SQL generation, as well as with the ORM.

For example, if the User class were assigned the schema “per_user”:

class User(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'user'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)

    __table_args__ = {'schema': 'per_user'}

On each request, the Session can be set up to refer to a different schema each time:

session = Session()
    "schema_translate_map": {"per_user": "account_one"}})

# will query from the ``account_one.user`` table


“Friendly” stringification of Core SQL constructs without a dialect

Calling str() on a Core SQL construct will now produce a string in more cases than before, supporting various SQL constructs not normally present in default SQL such as RETURNING, array indexes, and non-standard datatypes:

>>> from sqlalchemy import table, column
t>>> t = table('x', column('a'), column('b'))
>>> print(t.insert().returning(t.c.a, t.c.b))
INSERT INTO x (a, b) VALUES (:a, :b) RETURNING x.a, x.b

The str() function now calls upon an entirely separate dialect / compiler intended just for plain string printing without a specific dialect set up, so as more “just show me a string!” cases come up, these can be added to this dialect/compiler without impacting behaviors on real dialects.


The type_coerce function is now a persistent SQL element

The expression.type_coerce() function previously would return an object either of type BindParameter or Label, depending on the input. An effect this would have was that in the case where expression transformations were used, such as the conversion of an element from a Column to a BindParameter that’s critical to ORM-level lazy loading, the type coercion information would not be used since it would have been lost already.

To improve this behavior, the function now returns a persistent TypeCoerce container around the given expression, which itself remains unaffected; this construct is evaluated explicitly by the SQL compiler. This allows for the coercion of the inner expression to be maintained no matter how the statement is modified, including if the contained element is replaced with a different one, as is common within the ORM’s lazy loading feature.

The test case illustrating the effect makes use of a heterogeneous primaryjoin condition in conjunction with custom types and lazy loading. Given a custom type that applies a CAST as a “bind expression”:

class StringAsInt(TypeDecorator):
    impl = String

    def column_expression(self, col):
        return cast(col, Integer)

    def bind_expression(self, value):
        return cast(value, String)

Then, a mapping where we are equating a string “id” column on one table to an integer “id” column on the other:

class Person(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'person'
    id = Column(StringAsInt, primary_key=True)

    pets = relationship(
            '==cast(type_coerce(, Integer), Integer)'

class Pets(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'pets'
    id = Column('id', Integer, primary_key=True)
    person_id = Column('person_id', Integer)

Above, in the relationship.primaryjoin expression, we are using type_coerce() to handle bound parameters passed via lazyloading as integers, since we already know these will come from our StringAsInt type which maintains the value as an integer in Python. We are then using cast() so that as a SQL expression, the VARCHAR “id” column will be CAST to an integer for a regular non- converted join as with Query.join() or orm.joinedload(). That is, a joinedload of .pets looks like:

SELECT AS person_id, AS pets_1_id,
       pets_1.person_id AS pets_1_person_id
FROM person
LEFT OUTER JOIN pets AS pets_1
ON pets_1.person_id = CAST( AS INTEGER)

Without the CAST in the ON clause of the join, strongly-typed databases such as Postgresql will refuse to implicitly compare the integer and fail.

The lazyload case of .pets relies upon replacing the column at load time with a bound parameter, which receives a Python-loaded value. This replacement is specifically where the intent of our type_coerce() function would be lost. Prior to the change, this lazy load comes out as:

SELECT AS pets_id, pets.person_id AS pets_person_id
FROM pets
WHERE pets.person_id = CAST(CAST(%(param_1)s AS VARCHAR) AS INTEGER)
{'param_1': 5}

Where above, we see that our in-Python value of 5 is CAST first to a VARCHAR, then back to an INTEGER in SQL; a double CAST which works, but is nevertheless not what we asked for.

With the change, the type_coerce() function maintains a wrapper even after the column is swapped out for a bound parameter, and the query now looks like:

SELECT AS pets_id, pets.person_id AS pets_person_id
FROM pets
WHERE pets.person_id = CAST(%(param_1)s AS INTEGER)
{'param_1': 5}

Where our outer CAST that’s in our primaryjoin still takes effect, but the needless CAST that’s in part of the StringAsInt custom type is removed as intended by the type_coerce() function.


Key Behavioral Changes - ORM

Key Behavioral Changes - Core

TextClause.columns() will match columns positionally, not by name, when passed positionally

The new behavior of the TextClause.columns() method, which itself was recently added as of the 0.9 series, is that when columns are passed positionally without any additional keyword arguments, they are linked to the ultimate result set columns positionally, and no longer on name. It is hoped that the impact of this change will be low due to the fact that the method has always been documented illustrating the columns being passed in the same order as that of the textual SQL statement, as would seem intuitive, even though the internals weren’t checking for this.

An application that is using this method by passing Column objects to it positionally must ensure that the position of those Column objects matches the position in which these columns are stated in the textual SQL.

E.g., code like the following:

stmt = text("SELECT id, name, description FROM table")

# no longer matches by name
stmt = stmt.columns(, my_table.c.description,

Would no longer work as expected; the order of the columns given is now significant:

# correct version
stmt = stmt.columns(,, my_table.c.description)

Possibly more likely, a statement that worked like this:

stmt = text("SELECT * FROM table")
stmt = stmt.columns(,, my_table.c.description)

is now slightly risky, as the “*” specification will generally deliver columns in the order in which they are present in the table itself. If the structure of the table changes due to schema changes, this ordering may no longer be the same. Therefore when using TextClause.columns(), it’s advised to list out the desired columns explicitly in the textual SQL, though it’s no longer necessary to worry about the names themselves in the textual SQL.

Dialect Improvements and Changes - Postgresql

ARRAY and JSON types now correctly specify “unhashable”

As described in Changes regarding “unhashable” types, the ORM relies upon being able to produce a hash function for column values when a query’s selected entities mixes full ORM entities with column expressions. The hashable=False flag is now correctly set on all of PG’s “data structure” types, including postgresql.ARRAY and postgresql.JSON. The JSONB and HSTORE types already included this flag. For postgresql.ARRAY, this is conditional based on the postgresql.ARRAY.as_tuple flag, however it should no longer be necessary to set this flag in order to have an array value present in a composed ORM row.


Correct SQL Types are Established from Indexed Access of ARRAY, JSON, HSTORE

For all three of ARRAY, JSON and HSTORE, the SQL type assigned to the expression returned by indexed access, e.g. col[someindex], should be correct in all cases.

This includes:

  • The SQL type assigned to indexed access of an ARRAY takes into account the number of dimensions configured. An ARRAY with three dimensions will return a SQL expression with a type of ARRAY of one less dimension. Given a column with type ARRAY(Integer, dimensions=3), we can now perform this expression:

    int_expr = col[5][6][7]   # returns an Integer expression object

    Previously, the indexed access to col[5] would return an expression of type Integer where we could no longer perform indexed access for the remaining dimensions, unless we used cast() or type_coerce().

  • The JSON and JSONB types now mirror what Postgresql itself does for indexed access. This means that all indexed access for a JSON or JSONB type returns an expression that itself is always JSON or JSONB itself, unless the astext modifier is used. This means that whether the indexed access of the JSON structure ultimately refers to a string, list, number, or other JSON structure, Postgresql always considers it to be JSON itself unless it is explicitly cast differently. Like the ARRAY type, this means that it is now straightforward to produce JSON expressions with multiple levels of indexed access:

    json_expr = json_col['key1']['attr1'][5]
  • The “textual” type that is returned by indexed access of HSTORE as well as the “textual” type that is returned by indexed access of JSON and JSONB in conjunction with the astext modifier is now configurable; it defaults to Text in both cases but can be set to a user-defined type using the postgresql.JSON.astext_type or postgresql.HSTORE.text_type parameters.

#3499 #3487

The JSON cast() operation now requires .astext is called explicitly

As part of the changes in Correct SQL Types are Established from Indexed Access of ARRAY, JSON, HSTORE, the workings of the ColumnElement.cast() operator on postgresql.JSON and postgresql.JSONB no longer implictly invoke the postgresql.JSON.Comparator.astext modifier; Postgresql’s JSON/JSONB types support CAST operations to each other without the “astext” aspect.

This means that in most cases, an application that was doing this:

expr = json_col['somekey'].cast(Integer)

Will now need to change to this:

expr = json_col['somekey'].astext.cast(Integer)

ARRAY with ENUM will now emit CREATE TYPE for the ENUM

A table definition like the following will now emit CREATE TYPE as expected:

enum = Enum(
    'manager', 'place_admin', 'carwash_admin',
    'parking_admin', 'service_admin', 'tire_admin',
    'mechanic', 'carwasher', 'tire_mechanic', name="work_place_roles")

class WorkPlacement(Base):
    __tablename__ = 'work_placement'
    id = Column(Integer, primary_key=True)
    roles = Column(ARRAY(enum))

e = create_engine("postgresql://scott:tiger@localhost/test", echo=True)


CREATE TYPE work_place_roles AS ENUM (
    'manager', 'place_admin', 'carwash_admin', 'parking_admin',
    'service_admin', 'tire_admin', 'mechanic', 'carwasher',

CREATE TABLE work_placement (
    roles work_place_roles[],
    PRIMARY KEY (id)


The “postgres” module is removed

The sqlalchemy.dialects.postgres module, long deprecated, is removed; this has emitted a warning for many years and projects should be calling upon sqlalchemy.dialects.postgresql. Engine URLs of the form postgres:// will still continue to function, however.

Dialect Improvements and Changes - MySQL

MySQL JSON Support

A new type mysql.JSON is added to the MySQL dialect supporting the JSON type newly added to MySQL 5.7. This type provides both persistence of JSON as well as rudimentary indexed-access using the JSON_EXTRACT function internally. An indexable JSON column that works across MySQL and Postgresql can be achieved by using the types.JSON datatype common to both MySQL and Postgresql.


Added support for AUTOCOMMIT “isolation level”

The MySQL dialect now accepts the value “AUTOCOMMIT” for the create_engine.isolation_level and Connection.execution_options.isolation_level parameters:

connection = engine.connect()
connection = connection.execution_options(

The isolation level makes use of the various “autocommit” attributes provided by most MySQL DBAPIs.


No more generation of an implicit KEY for composite primary key w/ AUTO_INCREMENT

The MySQL dialect had the behavior such that if a composite primary key on an InnoDB table featured AUTO_INCREMENT on one of its columns which was not the first column, e.g.:

t = Table(
    'some_table', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True, autoincrement=False),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True, autoincrement=True),

DDL such as the following would be generated:

CREATE TABLE some_table (
    PRIMARY KEY (x, y),
    KEY idx_autoinc_y (y)

Note the above “KEY” with an auto-generated name; this is a change that found its way into the dialect many years ago in response to the issue that the AUTO_INCREMENT would otherwise fail on InnoDB without this additional KEY.

This workaround has been removed and replaced with the much better system of just stating the AUTO_INCREMENT column first within the primary key:

CREATE TABLE some_table (
    PRIMARY KEY (y, x)

Along with the change The .autoincrement directive is no longer implicitly enabled for a composite primary key column, composite primary keys with or without auto increment are now easier to specify; Column.autoincrement now defaults to the value "auto" and the autoincrement=False directives are no longer needed:

t = Table(
    'some_table', metadata,
    Column('x', Integer, primary_key=True),
    Column('y', Integer, primary_key=True, autoincrement=True),

Dialect Improvements and Changes - SQLite

Right-nested join workaround lifted for SQLite version 3.7.16

In version 0.9, the feature introduced by Many JOIN and LEFT OUTER JOIN expressions will no longer be wrapped in (SELECT * FROM ..) AS ANON_1 went through lots of effort to support rewriting of joins on SQLite to always use subqueries in order to achieve a “right-nested-join” effect, as SQLite has not supported this syntax for many years. Ironically, the version of SQLite noted in that migration note,, was the last version of SQLite to actually have this limitation! The next release was 3.7.16 and support for right nested joins was quietly added. In 1.1, the work to identify the specific SQLite version and source commit where this change was made was done (SQlite’s changelog refers to it with the cryptic phrase “Enhance the query optimizer to exploit transitive join constraints” without linking to any issue number, change number, or further explanation), and the workarounds present in this change are now lifted for SQLite when the DBAPI reports that version 3.7.16 or greater is in effect.


Dotted column names workaround lifted for SQLite version 3.10.0

The SQLite dialect has long had a workaround for an issue where the database driver does not report the correct column names for some SQL result sets, in particular when UNION is used. The workaround is detailed at Dotted Column Names, and requires that SQLAlchemy assume that any column name with a dot in it is actually a tablename.columnname combination delivered via this buggy behavior, with an option to turn it off via the sqlite_raw_colnames execution option.

As of SQLite version 3.10.0, the bug in UNION and other queries has been fixed; like the change described in Right-nested join workaround lifted for SQLite version 3.7.16, SQLite’s changelog only identifies it cryptically as “Added the colUsed field to sqlite3_index_info for use by the sqlite3_module.xBestIndex method”, however SQLAlchemy’s translation of these dotted column names is no longer required with this version, so is turned off when version 3.10.0 or greater is detected.

Overall, the SQLAlchemy ResultProxy as of the 1.0 series relies much less on column names in result sets when delivering results for Core and ORM SQL constructs, so the importance of this issue was already lessened in any case.


Improved Support for Remote Schemas

The SQLite dialect now implements Inspector.get_schema_names() and additionally has improved support for tables and indexes that are created and reflected from a remote schema, which in SQLite is a dataase that is assigned a name via the ATTACH statement; previously, the``CREATE INDEX`` DDL didn’t work correctly for a schema-bound table and the Inspector.get_foreign_keys() method will now indicate the given schema in the results. Cross-schema foreign keys aren’t supported.

Reflection of the name of PRIMARY KEY constraints

The SQLite backend now takes advantage of the “sqlite_master” view of SQLite in order to extract the name of the primary key constraint of a table from the original DDL, in the same way that is achieved for foreign key constraints in recent SQLAlchemy versions.


Dialect Improvements and Changes - SQL Server

Added transaction isolation level support for SQL Server

All SQL Server dialects support transaction isolation level settings via the create_engine.isolation_level and Connection.execution_options.isolation_level parameters. The four standard levels are supported as well as SNAPSHOT:

engine = create_engine(
    isolation_level="REPEATABLE READ"


String / varlength types no longer represent “max” explicitly on reflection

When reflecting a type such as String, Text, etc. which includes a length, an “un-lengthed” type under SQL Server would copy the “length” parameter as the value "max":

>>> from sqlalchemy import create_engine, inspect
>>> engine = create_engine('mssql+pyodbc://scott:tiger@ms_2008', echo=True)
>>> engine.execute("create table s (x varchar(max), y varbinary(max))")
>>> insp = inspect(engine)
>>> for col in insp.get_columns("s"):
...     print col['type'].__class__, col['type'].length
<class 'sqlalchemy.sql.sqltypes.VARCHAR'> max
<class 'sqlalchemy.dialects.mssql.base.VARBINARY'> max

The “length” parameter in the base types is expected to be an integer value or None only; None indicates unbounded length which the SQL Server dialect interprets as “max”. The fix then is so that these lengths come out as None, so that the type objects work in non-SQL Server contexts:

>>> for col in insp.get_columns("s"):
...     print col['type'].__class__, col['type'].length
<class 'sqlalchemy.sql.sqltypes.VARCHAR'> None
<class 'sqlalchemy.dialects.mssql.base.VARBINARY'> None

Applications which may have been relying on a direct comparison of the “length” value to the string “max” should consider the value of None to mean the same thing.


The legacy_schema_aliasing flag is now set to False

SQLAlchemy 1.0.5 introduced the legacy_schema_aliasing flag to the MSSQL dialect, allowing so-called “legacy mode” aliasing to be turned off. This aliasing attempts to turn schema-qualified tables into aliases; given a table such as:

account_table = Table(
    'account', metadata,
    Column('id', Integer, primary_key=True),
    Column('info', String(100)),

The legacy mode of behavior will attempt to turn a schema-qualified table name into an alias:

>>> eng = create_engine("mssql+pymssql://mydsn", legacy_schema_aliasing=True)
>>> print(
FROM customer_schema.account AS account_1

However, this aliasing has been shown to be unnecessary and in many cases produces incorrect SQL.

In SQLAlchemy 1.1, the legacy_schema_aliasing flag now defaults to False, disabling this mode of behavior and allowing the MSSQL dialect to behave normally with schema-qualified tables. For applications which may rely on this behavior, set the flag back to True.


Dialect Improvements and Changes - Oracle